Home›Lesson Plans›English Language Arts›Writing: Argument · Grade 7

Claims & Counterclaims: Arguing Both Sides

Seventh graders learn to build a strong argument — stating a clear claim, supporting it with reasons and evidence, and then acknowledging and answering the counterclaim — which makes their writing more convincing.

Grade 7Argument Writing50 minutes1 class periodReading WorkshopExplicit teaching4 StandardsCommon Core
Start the Lesson
Assign or share this lesson

Copy link works with Canvas, Schoology, Moodle and any other LMS — paste it in as a resource or assignment.

Lesson at a Glance

Everything you need before the bell rings

Learning Objectives

Students will be able to…

  • ✓Write a clear claim.
  • ✓Support it with evidence.
  • ✓Acknowledge a counterclaim.
  • ✓Write a rebuttal.
Essential Question

The strongest arguments don’t ignore the other side — they take it on! What are the parts of a powerful argument, and why does answering the opposing view make YOU more convincing?

0
Lesson Phases
0
Vocabulary Terms
0
Standards Aligned
0
Interactive Task
Argument Explorer · Interactive

The Argument Explorer

Project this and tap each part of an argument. Have students see how claim, evidence, counterclaim, and rebuttal work together!

⚖️ Explore the parts of an argument — tap eachTry it

The Lesson · Reading Workshop (Mini-Lesson · Practice · Share)

50 minutes, five moves

Tap any phase to open the teacher moves and student actions.

1

Connect — Take On the Other Side

5 min

The best arguments don’t ignore the other side — they answer it. Why?

👩‍🏫 Teacher Moves

  • Pose a debatable topic.
  • Ask about the opposing view.
  • Set the goal: claims and counterclaims.

🎒 Student Actions

  • Consider the topic.
  • Think of both sides.
  • Predict the idea.
2

Teach — The Parts

12 min

Teacher models.

👩‍🏫 Teacher Moves

  • State a claim with evidence.
  • Name the counterclaim.
  • Write a rebuttal.

🎒 Student Actions

  • Learn claim.
  • Learn counterclaim.
  • Learn rebuttal.
3

Active Engagement — Explore Together

13 min

Class uses the Argument Explorer.

👩‍🏫 Teacher Moves

  • Tap each part.
  • Identify it in an argument.
  • Build the pieces.

🎒 Student Actions

  • Tap each part.
  • Identify it.
  • Build them.
4

Practice — Practice

13 min

Students build arguments.

👩‍🏫 Teacher Moves

  • Write a claim with evidence.
  • Add a counterclaim.
  • Write a rebuttal.

🎒 Student Actions

  • Write a claim.
  • Add a counter.
  • Write a rebuttal.
5

Share — Share

5 min

Students share an argument.

👩‍🏫 Teacher Moves

  • Invite a claim and counterclaim.
  • Explain the rebuttal.
  • Hand out the exit ticket.

🎒 Student Actions

  • Share it.
  • Explain it.
  • Complete the exit ticket.
Standards Alignment

Built to the standards you report on

Aligned to the Common Core State Standards for English Language Arts.

CCSS
W.7.1a

Introduce claims, acknowledge alternate or opposing claims, and organize reasons and evidence.

CCSS
W.7.1

Write arguments to support claims with clear reasons and relevant evidence.

CCSS
RI.7.8

Trace and evaluate arguments and claims.

CCSS
SL.7.3

Evaluate a speaker’s argument and claims.

Differentiation

One lesson, every learner

Multilingual Learners

ELL / EMERGING READERS
  • Argument-part sentence frames.
  • Sentence frame: “Some say ___, but ___.”
  • Use a claim-counterclaim organizer.

Support & Access

IEP / 504
  • Start with claim and one reason.
  • Use a graphic organizer.
  • Add the counterclaim last.

Stretch & Extend

GIFTED / EARLY FINISHERS
  • Write a full argument essay.
  • Rebut multiple counterclaims.
  • Debate both sides.
Materials

What to gather

  • 📽️Projector / board
  • 🗂️Argument organizers
  • 💻The Argument Explorer
  • 🖍️Pencils
  • 📰Opinion articles
  • 🎫Exit-ticket slips
Vocabulary

Key terms — hover for a quick definition

claimthe main point being arguedargumenta claim with reasons and evidencereasonwhy the claim is trueevidencefacts and examples that support itcounterclaimthe opposing viewrebuttalthe answer to a counterclaimacknowledgeto recognize the other sidepersuasiveconvincing
Evaluate

Exit Ticket

Preview the three formative checks. Tap “Sample answer” to see what mastery looks like — hide them before you print for students.

QUESTION 1
What is a counterclaim?
The opposing view — what someone who disagrees with your claim would say.
QUESTION 2
What is a rebuttal?
Your answer to the counterclaim, explaining why your position still holds.
QUESTION 3
Why does addressing the other side make your argument stronger?
It shows you’ve considered all sides and can answer objections — which is more convincing.

Going deeper? The full essay.

Have students write a complete argument — claim, evidence, counterclaim, and rebuttal — on a topic they care about. A printable argument-writing sheet is in the ELA library.

Study · Flashcards

Study the key terms

Tap a card to flip it, then rate whether you knew it. Built from this lesson’s vocabulary.

🃏 Claims & CounterclaimsFlip
Card 1
Term
Tap to flip →
Meaning
0

Nice work!

Practice · Quiz

Check your understanding

A quick self-check with instant feedback, drawn from this lesson’s key terms.

📝 Claims & CounterclaimsQuiz
Score: 0
1 / 6
Question 1
0%

Nice work!

Practice · Worksheet

Printable worksheet

A print-and-go review sheet with a built-in answer key. Tap “Show answer key” to reveal answers, or print the clean version for students.

🖨️ Claims & CounterclaimsPrint
Name: ________________________
Date: ____________

Part A · Write the word that matches each meaning

Word bank: acknowledge, argument, claim, counterclaim, evidence, persuasive, reason, rebuttal
  1. the answer to a counterclaim
  2. convincing
  3. why the claim is true
  4. the main point being argued
  5. the opposing view
  6. facts and examples that support it
  7. a claim with reasons and evidence
  8. to recognize the other side

Part B · Show what you learned

  1. What is a counterclaim?
  2. What is a rebuttal?
  3. Why does addressing the other side make your argument stronger?
Answer key — Part A: 1) rebuttal · 2) persuasive · 3) reason · 4) claim · 5) counterclaim · 6) evidence · 7) argument · 8) acknowledge
Part B: 1) The opposing view — what someone who disagrees with your claim would say. 2) Your answer to the counterclaim, explaining why your position still holds. 3) It shows you’ve considered all sides and can answer objections — which is more convincing.